An essay on the causal theory of action

On the methodological-localist approach, the causal capacities of social entities are to be explained in terms of the structuring of preferences, worldviews, information, incentives, and opportunities for agents.

Jon Elster has also shed light on the ways in which the tools of rational choice theory support the construction of largescale sociological explanations; Elster For the social and historical sciences, this question comes down to this: The former follow the strategy of aggregating the results of individual-level choices into macro-level outcomes; the latter attempt to identify the factors that work behind the backs of agents to influence their choices.

For it is entirely likely that a microfoundational account of the determinants of individual action will include reference to social relations, norms, structures, cognitive frameworks, etc. This volume brings together leading figures working in action theory today to discuss issues relating to the CTA and its applications, which range from experimental philosophy to moral psychology.

This paper focuses on two central ideas: There are no causal powers at work within the domain of the social that do not proceed through structured individual agency. Charles Tilly emphasizes this point in his arguments for causal narratives in comparative sociology Tilly See Little for further exposition of these remarks.

And the repertoire of institutional choices for Chinese decision makers was significantly different from that available in early modern Europe Wong That is, we need to be able to provide an account of the causal mechanisms that convey social effects.

What exists is the socially constructed individual, within a congeries of concrete social relations and institutions. Social structures and institutions have causal properties and effects that play an important role within historical change the social causation thesis.

In other words, ML denies the possibility of reductionism from the level of the social to the level of a population of non-social individuals; rather, the individual is constituted by social facts, and the social facts are constituted by the current characteristics of the persons who make them up.

Some of the contributors defend the theory while others criticize it; some draw from historical sources What are the institutional embodiments at lower levels that secure the impact of law, taxation, conscription, contract enforcement, and other central elements of state behavior?

With individualism, this position embraces the point that individuals are the bearers of social structures and causes. Cartwright argues, for the natural sciences, that the concept of a real causal connection among a set of events is more fundamental than the concept of a law of nature CartwrightCartwright Here again we find the anti-positivist position leading to the conclusion that causal realism is a better basis for sociological research than competing Humean approaches to causation.

Action theory (philosophy)

Such a theory of prospective rationality underlies much of economics and other social sciences within the more sophisticated framework of rational choice. And in fact, most of the works by comparativist researchers who are sometimes characterized as structuralist are in fact compatible with the approach of methodological localism, including Skocpol and Tilly.

As the action -oriented perspective becomes more influential in philosophy of mind and philosophy of cognitive science, this volume offers a long-needed debate over foundational issues.

There is no action at a distance in social life; instead, individuals have the values that they have, the styles of reasoning, the funds of factual and causal beliefs, etc. This methodological-localism approach has numerous intellectual advantages: He argues that sociology requires better integration of theory and evidence, and argues that quantitative research comes closest to achieving the scientific aims of sociology.

So when we assert that a given social structure causes a given outcome, we need to be able to specify the local pathways through which individual actors embody this causal process. And second, it suggests a variety of ways of using available evidence to test or confirm a causal hypothesis: The general nature of the mechanisms that underlie sociological causation has been very much the subject of debate.

At each point we are invited to ask the question: The microfoundations thesis requires that we attempt to discover the pathways by which socially constituted individuals are influenced by distant social circumstances. The looseness of social organization emphasized in this account derives from the human ability to imagine new forms of social interaction; to innovate socially and collectively; to defect from social expectations.

This approach places central focus on the idea of a causal mechanism: Causal realism insists, finally, that the empirical evidence put forward must ultimately be assessed in terms of the credibility of the causal mechanisms that are postulated between cause and effect.

Furthermore, ML affirms the existence of social constructs beyond the purview of the individual actor or group. They exercise their causal powers through their influence on individual actions, beliefs, values, and choices the microfoundations thesis.The Causal Theory of Action is one way that philosophers try to explain why humans act the way we do.

Davidson is really the first to formulate and popularize the theory. He believed a person’s action was the result of a primary reason and belief under a description.

The causal theory of action (CTA) is widely recognized in the literature of the philosophy of action as the "standard story" of human action and agency -- the nearest.

A range of causal questions

Natural Agency argues that these different perspectives can be reconciled, despite the skepticism of many philosophers who have argued that free will is impossible under scientific determinism.

This skepticism is best overcome according to the author, by defending a causal theory of action, that is by establishing that actions are constituted Price: $ Natural Agency: An Essay on the Causal Theory of Action (Cambridge Studies in Philosophy) [John Bishop] on *FREE* shipping on qualifying offers.

From a moral point of view we think of ourselves as capable of responsible actions. From a scientific point of view we think of ourselves as animals whose behavior.

The causal theory of action is widely recognized in the literature of the philosophy of action as the "standard story" of human action and agency -- the nearest. Causal Explanation of Social Action: The Contribution of Max Weber and of Critical Realism to a Generative View of Causal Explanation in the Social Sciences.

Acta Sociologica 35 (2)(16).

An essay on the causal theory of action
Rated 3/5 based on 12 review